
Year |
Sport |
Athlete |
Honor |
| 2009-2010 | Women's Cross Country | Meagan Hudson | 5th Place |
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Meagan Hudson | 5th Place | |
Women's Soccer | Sara O'Donnell | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Wrestling | Zach Meury | 8th Place | |
| Anton Prater | 5th Place | ||
| Women's Wrestling | Schuyler Brown | 2nd Place | |
| Veronica Carlson | 2nd Place | ||
| Helen Maroulis | 1st Place | ||
| Desiree Memea | 3rd Place | ||
| Amy Whitbeck | 2nd Place | ||
| 2008-2009 | Men's Basketball | Dane Rawlins | Honorable Mention |
| Women's Basketball | Alexis Rhoades | Honorable Mention | |
| Women's Cross Country | Meagan Hudson | ||
| Men's Lacrosse | Matthew Hogan | Honorable Mention | |
| Outdoor Men's Track & Field | Junior Hines | ||
| Outdoor Women's Track & Field | Meagan Hudson | ||
| Women's Volleyball | Brittany Lukasek | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Wrestling | Matt Collum | ||
| Clarence Neeley | |||
| Ike Okenwa | |||
| Women's Wrestling | Shamaine Danner | ||
| Desire Memea | |||
| 2007-2008 | Women's Cross Country | Meagan Hudson | |
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Meagan Hudson | ||
| Women's Volleyball | Brittany Lukasek | Third Team | |
| Men's Wrestling | Matt Collum | 3rd Place | |
| Nigel Kinworthy | 6th Place | ||
| Ike Okenwa | 7th Place | ||
| 2006-2007 | Baseball | Brandon Patek | Honorable Mention |
| Men's Cross Country | Denis-Bull Olinga | ||
| Men's Golf | Danny Manselle | Second Team | |
| Women's Golf | Prank Dejsubha | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Steve Bender | ||
| Fernando Edwards | |||
| Jamaury Harris | |||
| Kenneth Kibii | |||
| Vincent Morogah | |||
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Nickesha Anderson | ||
| LaShayla Bell | |||
| Chadiola Chumney | |||
| Coreen Ellis | |||
| Meagan Hudson | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Meagan Hudson | ||
| Men's Volleyball | Ivan Lugonja | ||
| Women's Volleyball | Tracey Abell | Honorable Mention | |
| Ana Mercado |
NAIA Player of the Year | ||
| 2005-2006 | Baseball | Brad Arnett | Honorable Mention |
| Pedro Perez | Honorable Mention | ||
| Scott Thomas | Second Team | ||
| Men's Basketball | Franklin Penn | Honorable Mention | |
| Women's Basketball | LaTrice McMichel | Third Team | |
| Men's Cross Country | Denis-Bull Olinga | ||
| Men's Golf | Danny Manselle | Honorable Mention | |
| Chris Naegel | |||
| Men's Soccer | Hernan Merino | Second Team | |
| Rackley Thomas | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Duran Brown | ||
| Orlando Collins | |||
| Michael Gusbeth | |||
| Jamaury Harris | |||
| Cornell Rose | |||
| Genttell Sykes | |||
| Keron Thomas | |||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Orlando Collins | ||
| Fernando Edwards | |||
| Jerome Foster | |||
| Michael Gusbeth | |||
| Steve Hammonds | |||
| Jamaury Harris | |||
| Vincent Morogah | |||
| Denis-Bull Olinga | |||
| Shawn Silvera | |||
| Kemar Smith | |||
| Genttell Sykes | |||
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Nickesha Anderson | ||
| Rachel Baldwin | |||
| Lanece Clarke | |||
| Denele DeVerteuil | |||
| Sherline Duncan | |||
| Coreen Ellis | |||
| Jackie Fleddermann | |||
| Seidre Forde | |||
| Ashley Harris | |||
| Nikkita Holder | |||
| Nadine Marsh | |||
| Margaret Nakintu | |||
| Shernelle Nicholls | |||
| Maresia Pencil | |||
| Charminique Ray | |||
| Betty Rotich | |||
| Nicola Smith | |||
| Ladonna St Louis | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Nickehsa Anderson | ||
| Rachel Baldwin | |||
| Lanece Clarke | |||
| Jackie Fleddermann | |||
| Seidre Forde | |||
| Ashley Harris | |||
| Nikkita Holder | |||
| Nadina Marsh | |||
| Shernelle Nicholls | |||
| Maresia Pencil | |||
| Charminique Ray | |||
| Betty Rotich | |||
| Women's Volleyball | Ana Mercado | First Team | |
| Men's Wrestling | Nigel Kinworthy | 6th Place | |
| Chas Skelly | 7th Place | ||
| 2004-2005 | Baseball | Jesse Bahr | Honorable Mention |
| Jake McMurran | Second Team | ||
| Men's Basketball | Ryan Edwards | Honorable Mention | |
| Jason Kaplan | Second Team | ||
| Women's Basketball | Domonique Brown | Honorable Mention | |
| LaTrice McMichel | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Cross Country | Denis-Bull Olinga | ||
| Tom Humphries | |||
| Men's Soccer | Lawrence Olum | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Volleyball | Ivan Lugonja | ||
| Women's Volleyball | Renata Pedriera | Third Team | |
| Marijana Stanic | Honorable Mention | ||
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Nickesha Anderson | ||
| Sherline Duncan | |||
| Jackie Fleddermann | |||
| Shernelle Nicholls | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Nickesha Anderson | 100, 200, 400 Champion | |
| Rachel Baldwin | |||
| Sherline Duncan | |||
| Jackie Fleddermann | |||
| Shernelle Nicholls | |||
| Maresia Pencil | |||
| Charminique Ray | |||
| Nicola Smith | |||
| 2003-2004 | Baseball | Dave Allison | Honorable Mention |
| Garrett Bauer | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Basketball | Jason Kaplan | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Soccer | Lawrence Olum | Honorable Mention | |
| Women's Soccer | Andrea Hamilton | Honorable Mention | |
| Fabiana Mendoza | Honorable Mention | ||
| Salome Ojosh | Honorable Mention | ||
| Jamie Raub | |||
| Men's Volleyball | Ivan Lugonja | ||
| Men's Wrestling | Woodrow Harris | First Team | |
| Claude Robinson | Second Team | ||
| 2002-2003 | Baseball | Jon Kars | Honorable Mention |
| Jason McStoots | Honorable Mention | ||
| Joe Sester | Honorable Mention | ||
| Jeff Sherman | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Basketball | George Mdluli | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Soccer | Mike Burgund | Honorable Mention | |
| Women's Soccer | Salome Ojosh | Honorable Mention | |
| Aubrey Pepper | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Volleyball | Dejan Jovic | First Team | |
| Toplica Popovic | First Team | ||
| Women's Vollebyall | Meleisha Purcell | Second Team | |
| Terri Rauhut | Honorable Mention | ||
| Brandi Schroeder | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Wrestling | Woodrow Harris | 2nd Place | |
| William Riffe | 4th Place | ||
| 2001-2002 | Baseball | Mike Chornak | Honorable Mention |
| Dominick Gruttadauria | Honorable Mention | ||
| Jon Kars | Honorable Mention | ||
| Jason McStoots | Second Team | ||
| Jeff Sherman | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Basketball | Adam Riva | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Soccer | Brian Cross | Honorable Mention | |
| Sheldon Richard | Honorable Mention | ||
| Addae Rique | Honorable Mention | ||
| Women's Soccer | Fabiana Mendoza | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Volleyball | Brandon Whiteside | ||
| Women's Vollebyall | Meleisha Purcell | Honorable Mention | |
| Brandi Schroeder | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2000-2001 | Baseball | Damon Burkhart | Honorable Mention |
| Men's Basketball | Mike Hendren | Third Team | |
| Women's Volleyball | Jen Freund | First Team | |
| Brandi Schroeder | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1999-2000 | Baseball | Julio Campos | Honorable Mention |
| Wilfredo Gonzalez | Honorable Mention | ||
| Luis Raul Martinez | Honorable Mention | ||
| Women's Volleyball | Jessica Evans | Honorable Mention | |
| 1998-1999 | Baseball | Julio Campos | First Team |
| Baseball | Leo Santiago | Honorable Mention | |
| 1997-1998 | Baseball | Brian Buchmeier | Honorable Mention |
| Juan Medina | Honorable Mention | ||
| Chad Mirr | Honorable Mention | ||
| Joey Pipes | Honorable Mention | ||
| Women's Soccer | Carrie Obermoeller | First Team | |
| 1996-1997 | Women's Soccer | Carrie Obermoeller | Honorable Mention |
| 1995-1996 | Baseball | Brian Yaeger | |
| Women's Volleyball | Leslie Benson | Honorable Mention | |
| 1994-1995 | Baseball | Rob Frost | |
| Men's Basketball | Keith Joseph | ||
| Cheerleading | Jamie Newcomb | ||
| 1993-1994 | Baseball | Dan Soaib | Honorable Mention |
| Men's Basketball | Harold Frost | Honorable Mention | |
| Kevin Zeuschel | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1992-1993 | Baseball | Bob Radosevich | Honorable Mention |
| 1991-1992 | Men's Basketball | Keith Joseph | |
| 1990-1991 | Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Felicia Amajali | |
| Faith Idehen | |||
| Sandra Kidd | |||
| Barbara Moore | |||
| Wendy Solomon | |||
| Sandra Stepney | |||
| Belinda Watts | |||
| 1989-1990 | Baseball | Tim Kirt | Honorable Mention |
| Sean Sadler | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Basketball | Chris Peay | Honorable Mention | |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Enrique German | ||
| Michael Gregory | |||
| Etim Otudor | |||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Enrique German | ||
| Michael Gregory | |||
| Etim Otudor | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Felicia Amajali | ||
| Kerry Evans | |||
| Felisha Harris | |||
| Sandra Kidd | |||
| Dawn Mills | |||
| Wendy Solomon | |||
| Sandra Stepney | |||
| Belinda Watts | |||
| Reflaye Williams | |||
| 1988-1989 | Baseball | Pat Gerwitz | Honorable Mention |
| Tom Leach | Honorable Mention | ||
| Chris Robinson | Second Team | ||
| Eddie Ross | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Anthony Pierson | ||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Felicia Amajali | ||
| Kerry Evans | |||
| Felisha Harris | |||
| Sandra Kidd | |||
| Dawn Mills | |||
| Wendy Solomon | |||
| Sandra Stepney | |||
| Belinda Watts | |||
| Reflaye Williams | |||
| 1987-1988 | Baseball | Rich Alotta | Honorable Mention |
| Charlie Jarvis | Honorable Mention | ||
| Keith Kimberlin | Honorable Mention | ||
| Men's Cross Country | Jamie Burnham | ||
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Jamie Burnham | ||
| Mike Hall | |||
| Anthony Pierson | |||
| Cecil Shy | |||
| Marvin Wright | |||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Paul Brigman | ||
| Jamie Burnham | |||
| Anthony Pierson | |||
| Cecil Shy | |||
| Eric West | |||
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Kathy Burgdorf | ||
| Kelly Cox | |||
| Dorothy Young | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Kathy Burgdorf | ||
| Kelly Cox | |||
| Lorna Evans | |||
| Georgia Gibson | |||
| Evelina James | |||
| Miriam Otten | |||
| Dorothy Young | |||
| 1986-1987 | Baseball | Chuck Duquette | |
| Charlie Jarvis | |||
| Men's Cross Country | Tom DeClue | ||
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Jamie Burnham | ||
| Anthony Leaks | |||
| Anthony Pierson | |||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Jamie Burnham | ||
| Tony Chatman | |||
| Anthony Leaks | |||
| Terry Plunkett | |||
| LeTorre Swinney | |||
| Ron Walton | |||
| Larry Woodson | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Kelly Cox | ||
| Jenny Evans | |||
| Tiny Evans | |||
| Miriam Otten | |||
| Dorothy Young | |||
| 1985-1986 | Men's Cross Country | Dan Bryant | |
| Softball | Nancy Albers | Second Team | |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Dan Bryant | ||
| Jamie Burnham | |||
| Tony Chatman | |||
| Gary Jones | |||
| Anthony Leaks | |||
| Anthony Pierson | |||
| Gene Pitman | |||
| Terry Plunkett | |||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Jamie Burnham | ||
| Tony Chatman | |||
| Anthony Leaks | |||
| LeTorre Swinney | |||
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Stephanie Cameron | ||
| Kelly Cox | |||
| Laura Evans | |||
| Lorna Evans | |||
| Dorothy Young | |||
| 1984-1985 | Men's Cross Country | Dan Bryant | |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Anthony Leaks | ||
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Tony Chatman | ||
| Anthony Leaks | |||
| LeTorre Swinney | |||
| Larry Woodson | |||
| 1983-1984 | Baseball | Pat Devine | |
| Men's Cross Country | Dan Bryant | ||
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Dan Bryant | ||
| 1980-1981 | Men's Basketball | Paul Howard | Honorable Mention |
| 1977-1978 | Baseball | Pat Brady | |
| Mike Ferguson | |||
| Chris Heck | |||
| Kirk Herweck | |||
| Mark Smith | |||
| 1976-1977 | Baseball | Mark Smith | |
| 1975-1976 | Baseball | John Hartin | |
| Kirk Herweck | |||
| Mark Sabo | |||
| Joe Thurman | |||
| 1972-1973 | Men's Basketball | Bill Summer | Honorable Mention |