| Year | Sport |
Athlete |
| 2010-2011 | Men's Basketball | Kyle Ford |
| Women's Basketball | Andrea Seabaugh | |
Women's Volleyball Women's Soccer
|
Kalia Bequette Jessica Bowman Lucy Ford Kaitlyn Gunkel Renata Fanti | |
|
Nicole Hazlett
| ||
| l | Janee Patton | |
| Men's Wrestling Men's Lacrosse | Clayton Olsson Ben Hughes | |
2009-2010 |
Women's Lacrosse Men's Track and Field Softball Baseball Cheerleading Men's Bowling Men's Tennis Women's Tennis Women's Bowling Baseball |
Jessica Cuggino Patricia Dreyer Steve Kassel Tim Glockner Danielle Hayden Stacey Launius Torrie Yeast Jacob Greminger Russell Hendricks Vanessa Nelson Audrey Chamberlain Joel Barbarick Anthony Burgess Mike Peters Curtis Taylor Corey Young Nicholas Jannett Kristen Roberts Lindsay Dixon Rebecca Royce Alexis Shinn Jessica Strand Jessica Young Jen Donahue Hannah Joy Hirae Jacob Greminger |
| Baseball |
Russell Hendricks | |
| Women's Cross Country | Katie Cline | |
| Men's Golf |
Kyle Jasper | |
| Women's Golf |
Katherine Dunlap | |
| Men's Lacrosse |
Matt Mercer | |
| Men's Lacrosse |
Dave Shaw | |
| Men's Soccer |
Daniel Eddins | |
| Women's Soccer |
Heather Allen | |
| Softball | Danielle Hayden | |
| Softball |
Stacey Launius | |
| Softball |
Jessica Robinson | |
| Softball |
Torrie Yeast | |
| Men's Tennis |
Calvin Kohler | |
| Women's Tennis |
Lindsay Dixon | |
| Men's Track & Field |
Steve Kassel | |
| Women's Track & Field |
Katie Cline | |
| Men's Volleyball |
Jedson Barbosa | |
| Women's Volleyball |
Kaila Bequette | |
| Women's Volleyball |
Erica DeVilbiss | |
| Men's Wrestling Women's Bowling Women's Bowling Women's Bowling Women's Bowling | Clayton Olsson Hannah-Joy Hirae Rebecca Royce Jessica Strand Jessica Young | |
| 2008-2009 | Baseball | Dayne Dyer |
| Women's Basketball | Miroslava Harcegova | |
| Men's Bowling | Curtis Taylor | |
| Men's Bowling | James Wesson | |
| Women's Bowling | Brandy Gates | |
| Women's Bowling | Jessica Young | |
| Men's Golf | Zack Daugherty | |
| Men's Lacrosse | Matthew Hogan | |
| Men's Soccer | Daniel Eddins | |
| Men's Soccer | William Price | |
| Women's Soccer | Heather Allen | |
| Women's Soccer | Kathryn Prior | |
| Women's Soccer | Ashley Roberts | |
| Softball | Jessica Robinson | |
| Men's Tennis | Calvin Kohler | |
| Women's Track & Field | Aigner Johnson | |
| Women's Volleyball | Erica DeVilbiss | |
| Women's Volleyball | Brittany Lukasek | |
| Men's Wrestling | Clayton Olsson | |
| 2007-2008 | Women's Basketball | Miroslava Harcegova |
| Men's Bowling | Curtis Taylor | |
| Men's Bowling | James Wesson | |
| Men's Bowling | Corey Young | |
| Men's Bowling Women's Bowling Men's Golf |
M.J. Norris Rebecca Royce Zack Daugherty | |
| 2006-2007 | Men's Basketball | Ryan Byrne |
| Women's Basketball | Megan Brown | |
| Women's Basketball | Nicole Thompson | |
| Men's Bowling | M.J. Norris | |
| Men's Bowling | Curtis Taylor | |
| Women's Bowling | Becca Royce | |
| Men's Golf | Cullen Carstens | |
| Men's Golf | Patrick Ryan Howell | |
| Women's Golf | Melinda Boles | |
| Women's Golf | Crystal Stadter | |
| Men's Soccer | Miles Abel | |
| Women's Soccer | Crystal Stadter | |
| Men's Track & Field | Kyle Proemsey | |
| 2005-2006 | Women's Basketball | Megan Brown |
| Women's Basketball | Nicole Thompson | |
| Women's Basketball | Holly Tichy | |
| Men's Bowling | Tony Schrader | |
| Men's Bowling | Curtis Taylor | |
| Men's Bowling | Corey Young | |
| Women's Bowling | Stacy Clubbs | |
| Men's Golf | Cullen Carstens | |
| Men's Golf | Ryan Patrick Howell | |
| Women's Golf | Jessica Grimes | |
| Men's Soccer | Josh Lydon | |
| Men's Soccer | Ricky Todd | |
| 2004-2005 | Women's Basketball | Holly Tichy |
| Men's Bowling | Corey Young | |
| Women's Bowling | Julie Burton | |
| Women's Bowling | Stacy Clubbs | |
| Women's Bowling | Jen Donahue | |
| Men's Golf | Adam Loyd | |
| Men's Soccer | Josh Lydon | |
| Men's Soccer | Ricky Todd | |
| Women's Soccer | Fabiana Mendoza | |
| Women's Track & Field | Jackie Fledderman | |
| Women's Track & Field | Kate Murphy | |
| Women's Track & Field | Jennifer Sproehnle | |
| 2003-2004 | Men's Golf | Adam Loyd |
| Women's Soccer | Jackie Corbett | |
| Women's Soccer | Jennifer Sproehnle | |
| 2002-2003 | Baseball | David Allison |
| Baseball | Josh Mills | |
| Women's Soccer | Leah Gamblin | |
| Women's Soccer | Jamie Raub | |
| 2001-2002 | Men's Golf | Brett Eddy |
| Women's Soccer | Leah Gamblin | |
| Women's Soccer | Jamie Raub | |
| Men's Wrestling | James Ott | |
| 2000-2001 | Men's Basketball | Jordan Stone |
| Women's Basketball | Jennifer Bixler | |
| Women's Basketball | Eva Gassenberger | |
| Men's Golf | Brett Eddy | |
| 1999-2000 | Women's Soccer | Becky Sutton |
| Women's Soccer | Casey Neuwirth | |
| Women's Basketball | Rebecca Wilson | |
1998-1999 |
Women's Soccer |
Alycia Brock |
| Women's Soccer | Brittney Russell | |
| Women's Soccer | Hannah Stroud | |
| Women's Soccer | Rebecca Sutton | |
| Women's Basketball | Rebecca Wilson | |
1997-1998 |
Men's Basketball |
Joshua Franklin |
| Men's Golf | Grant White | |
| 1996-1997 | Men's Golf | Grant White |
| 1995-1996 | Women's Basketball | Sherri McFarland |
| Women's Basketball | Wendy Reeves | |
| Women's Volleyball Baseball |
Stephany Dueker Rob Garrett | |
| 1994-1995 | Women's Basketball | Sherri McFarland |
| Women's Basketball | Wendy Reeves | |
| 1988-1989 | Men's Track & Field | Anthony Smith |
| 1987-1988 | Women's Cross Country | Kathy Frailing |
